The "Wreck Photo"
Since 1998, TIGHAR has been speculating whether there is any chance that the wreck shown in this photo might be Earhart's Electra:
Lockheed Electra 10-AAuckland, NZ
When I was in Auckland, I took photos of an Electra 10-A. These photos support the argument that the cowling of the Electra doesn't come off the way the cowling did of the aircraft in the wreck photo.
The Electra cowling is made in three parts. You can see the parting lines in the picture below at 12, 4, and 8 o'clock.
This is a closeup of the 4 o'clock junction.
This is a closeup of the 8 o'clock junction.
When the Electra cowl is taken off, the engine looks like this:
To my eye, the engine in the wreck photo looks much more like the engine used on the Japanese KI-54:
I am not saying that the wreck can be positively identified as a KI-54; I'm just pointing out that the engine in the photo bears a stronger resemblance to known Japanese engines than to the engines known to have been used on Amelia's Electra. To make the Electra look like the plane in the wreck photo, someone would have to slice the cowls to pieces, leaving only the forward portion intact. That's a heck of a lot of work. "ATAIU" on the Jeep may stand for "Allied Technical Air Intelligence Unit." The website where I found this picture does not explain its provenance. The two officers (?) on the right certainly look like Allies rather than Japanese, to my untrained eye. Hmm. This gives rise to a new theory for the wreck photo: it may be a picture of a Japanese warplane that is being scavenged by ATAIU. Niki Zanzonico argues forcefully and persuasively that the Wreck Photo is a KI-54.Mark Guimond"It is completely bogus of course, and it takes absolutely no fund-wasting forensic photo analysis to clearly and definitively come to that conclusion. Why? Simple! No aircraft that I know of that was powered by a single-row P&W engine (i.e. R-985 or R-1340) was ever equipped with a ring-cowl. I have worked on, flown in, photographed, or just 'been around' Beavers, Otters, Norsemans, Twin-Beeches (D-18/AT-11/C-45), Electras, Mallards, Gooses, and maybe a couple more. All have the same type of three-section cowlings as you can clearly see on the ground in front of NR-16020 following the takeoff ground-loop that ended the first flight attempt. You can see for yourselves if you Google up photos of the aircraft just mentioned. The separate ring-cowl was used on many British, European and Japanese aircraft of the period because it served double-duty as the exhaust collector ring, since the exhaust ports on the engines faced forward for better cooling. These rings were made of steel and were mounted directly to the engine, not to the airframe. P&W had the cooling problem under control and the exhaust ports faced aft." ATAIU"Captain Frank T. McCoy and Technical Sergeant Francis Williams
helped organize a Materiel Section for technical intelligence operations
in Melbourne, Australia, in 1942. In addition to providing information
on aircraft and weapons performance, Captain McCoy and Sergeant Williams
assigned code names to Japanese aircraft--feminine names for bombers
and masculine names for fighters. It may not be surprising that "Frank"
and "Frances" became the names of two Japanese aircraft. In October
1944, Lieutenant Colonel Frank Mccoy became officer-in-charge of the
newly formed Technical Air Intelligence Unit attached to the Far East
Air Forces." "TAIU IN CONTROL In October 1944, a Technical Air Intelligence
Unit (TAIU) was formed and attached to the Far East Air Forces. Frank
McCoy, by then a Lt Colonel, was designated Officer-in-Charge. Under
his direction, TAIU took possession and control of all captured Japanese
aircraft and equipment in the Pacific Theater. Earlier in the same
year, a Technical Air Intelligence Center (TAIC) was officially established
in Washington, D.C. (Anacostia), as a joint Army-Navy organization
with British participation. To this center was assigned the responsibility
of collection, evaluation, and dissemination of all technical intelligence
on the Japanese Air Forces. This center worked closely with TAIU in
the field and absorbed part of its experienced personnel. TAIC, during
1945 and 1946, also worked closely and harmoniously with intelligence
at Wright Field. When it was deactivated in the summer of 1946, some
of its key personnel were assigned to technical intelligence at Wright
Field, along with those functions which pertained to the Air Corps." "Thereafter, the first TAIU was set up as a joint
USAAF/USN/RAAF organization in Australia in early 1943. This particular
unit absorbed a small team from the Directorate of Intelligence, HQ
Allied Forces, who were developing the Code Name system for Japanese
aircraft they had started in 1942. A second, known as the Allied TAIU
for South East Asia (ATAIU-SEA), followed in Calcutta in late 1943 as
a joint RAF/USAAF Allied unit. Then, in mid 1944, the USN personnel
from the TAIU in Australia were withdrawn to NAS Anacosta, near Washington
DC, to become the TAIC (Technical Air Intelligence Centre), whose purpose
was to centralise and co-ordinate work of test centres in the United
States with work of TAIUs in the field. The operation in Australia was
reformed to function thereafter as TAIU for the South West Pacific Area
(TAIU-SWPA) and eventually moved to the Philippines in early 1945. Two
other operations were also set up, TAIU for the Pacific Ocean Area (TAIU-POA)
as a USN unit to trawl the various Pacific Islands for aircraft and
TAIU for China (TAIU-CHINA) under control of Chiang Kai Shek's Nationalists." KI-54 FuselagePhotos from Alfred Hendrickson, though not taken by him. They show a KI-54 fuselage in a museum.Ric Gillespie, Founder and Director of TIGHAR, October 10, 2006:
Grumman Goose? |